|
Post by MTS on Dec 2, 2014 8:28:53 GMT
LINKNo retrospective charge, he slipped and fell apparently
|
|
|
Post by ek on Dec 2, 2014 8:38:18 GMT
The fucking charge should be headed in Collim's direction for being totally inept
|
|
|
Post by maroon1 on Dec 2, 2014 8:53:23 GMT
The dives by Lee Mculloch and Nicky Law the week before were worse than Guidetti's I reckon. I know the question has only been asked because the Celtic player benefited from the ref's howler but for me the Sevco players should be getting hauled over the coals for their bits of blatant cheating
|
|
|
Post by Dedrokstar on Dec 2, 2014 9:49:13 GMT
I don't think Guidetti dived but he is guilty of cheating by then claiming a pen. I agree EK - Collum was determined to give it. He gave a cowardly stare towards his assistant begging him for a signal. When that didn't come the wee shit had to give it himself.
I don't agree with posters on here who say Collum isn't bent. He is. He always referees these games from Septic's perspective, ergo he doesn't apply the rules evenly, ergo he is a cheat. Absolutely no doubt in my mind.
|
|
|
Post by MTS on Dec 2, 2014 9:53:58 GMT
The dives by Lee Mculloch and Nicky Law the week before were worse than Guidetti's I reckon. I know the question has only been asked because the Celtic player benefited from the ref's howler but for me the Sevco players should be getting hauled over the coals for their bits of blatant cheating Craig Thomson should have booked McCulloch and Law for simulation, also failed to send off Miller and Boyd. Not a great 2 weeks for Scotland's best 2 whistlers
|
|
|
Post by waynesbrain on Dec 2, 2014 10:38:33 GMT
Ok so Guidetti slipped. How's about a wee bit of honesty then John? Tell Collum you slipped, that there was no contact and it's not a penalty.
I know people will say this is unrealistic in today's win at all cost environment, but I remember Do Canio passing up an open goal a few years back by stopping play when he realised the keeper was down injured ( if memory serves me right) and he received plaudits for his gentlemanly behaviour.
The fact that Guidetti accepted the penalty, took and scored the penalty, then celebrated in front of those wanks as if he'd scored the winner in a champions league final tells me everything I need to know about the man.
As for Collum, an even more despicable human being. If possible.
|
|
|
Post by juniorjambo93 on Dec 2, 2014 19:22:14 GMT
You know what would have been nice? Since it was either a slip or a dive, he could have said to the referee as I saw Ronaldinho do years ago, that it was not a penalty. Show some sportsmanship you fucking little runt.
|
|
|
Post by drj1956 on Dec 2, 2014 19:24:54 GMT
I don't think Guidetti dived but he is guilty of cheating by then claiming a pen. I agree EK - Collum was determined to give it. He gave a cowardly stare towards his assistant begging him for a signal. When that didn't come the wee shit had to give it himself. I don't agree with posters on here who say Collum isn't bent. He is. He always referees these games from Septic's perspective, ergo he doesn't apply the rules evenly, ergo he is a cheat. Absolutely no doubt in my mind. Don't agree Dedrock I really do think he is just inept . Remember the pen he gave the Hun against Celtic when he had his back to the incident
|
|
|
Post by parkhead98 on Dec 2, 2014 19:52:02 GMT
Sorry, but no slip as far as I'm concerned. Took a dive and gave an inept and corrupt official the chance he was waiting for.
Guidetti is a cheating cnut!
As for Gollum, I firmly believe that he was a contributing factor as to why around 5,000 Hearts fans stayed away on the day. They just knew he would influence the game in someway, more than likely, in Celtics favour. Maybe if he'd awarded Hearts a free kick just before Gomis' reckless lunge, then there would've been no lunge? He also let Brown get away with persistent fouling, with at least three of those fouls coming after he'd warned the player.
Awful ref.
Oh aye, and Gollum is a cheating cnut too!
|
|
|
Post by edinburghscott on Dec 2, 2014 19:59:53 GMT
Ok so Guidetti slipped. How's about a wee bit of honesty then John? Tell Collum you slipped, that there was no contact and it's not a penalty. I know people will say this is unrealistic in today's win at all cost environment, but I remember Do Canio passing up an open goal a few years back by stopping play when he realised the keeper was down injured ( if memory serves me right) and he received plaudits for his gentlemanly behaviour. The fact that Guidetti accepted the penalty, took and scored the penalty, then celebrated in front of those wanks as if he'd scored the winner in a champions league final tells me everything I need to know about the man. As for Collum, an even more despicable human being. If possible. Dead right. Would love to have seen a wee bit of honesty here. For what it's worth I think it was a slip. Think of the respect the guy would have got had he admitted that he lost his footing and that there was no contact. How fantastic such a gesture would have been and what an example to the kids watching. A high profile sportsman showing...sportsmanship. Instead he cheated. Fud! What would you think had a Hearts player done that? Personally I would be delighted and proud. Winning by cheating is not winning. Integrity is everything.
|
|
|
Post by K19 on Dec 3, 2014 8:53:25 GMT
A Hearts player would have done the same i.e. kept his mouth shut and taken the pen. I don't think he dived either so let's not get distracted from the main issue - that being the referee was certain that it was a penalty therefore his judgement is clearly lacking.
If Guidetti did anything wrong, apart from keeping his mouth shut, it was in taking the penalty himself. I think that's where he lost any claim to integrity as he could easily have left it to someone else and said he didn't make any claim for a pen and didn't have any say in the outcome of the ref's decision either so it's not his problem.
That said, the manager shouldn't have said it was a penalty and the way the celtic players surrounded the ref for the sending off was terrible, including the big number 6 applauding the ref and giving him the thumbs up when he issued the red card. The number 6's actions were more shameful than Guidetti's imo.
|
|
|
Post by MTS on Dec 3, 2014 10:08:59 GMT
I saw a quote from ex referee Kenny Clark saying that Willie Collum gave the penalty because he had a "HUNCH" I thought referees had to be 100% certain before they gave a penalty.
Interesting quote from Deila in the Sun today saying the Scottish Referees are the best in Europe, comparing them with the referees in the Europa League.
Maybe that's because in the Europa League they are not biased or cheats.
|
|
|
Post by maroon1 on Dec 3, 2014 10:29:39 GMT
Ok so Guidetti slipped. How's about a wee bit of honesty then John? Tell Collum you slipped, that there was no contact and it's not a penalty. I know people will say this is unrealistic in today's win at all cost environment, but I remember Do Canio passing up an open goal a few years back by stopping play when he realised the keeper was down injured ( if memory serves me right) and he received plaudits for his gentlemanly behaviour. The fact that Guidetti accepted the penalty, took and scored the penalty, then celebrated in front of those wanks as if he'd scored the winner in a champions league final tells me everything I need to know about the man. As for Collum, an even more despicable human being. If possible. Dead right. Would love to have seen a wee bit of honesty here. For what it's worth I think it was a slip. Think of the respect the guy would have got had he admitted that he lost his footing and that there was no contact. How fantastic such a gesture would have been and what an example to the kids watching. A high profile sportsman showing...sportsmanship. Instead he cheated. Fud! What would you think had a Hearts player done that? Personally I would be delighted and proud. Winning by cheating is not winning. Integrity is everything. Great post mate.....totally agree, well worth a BOOM
|
|